Mumbai: The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation’s (BMC) controversial plan to replace recently allotted Mahindra Scorpio-N SUVs with Toyota Innova Crysta vehicles has taken a political turn, with the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) staging a symbolic protest by sending toy Innova cars to the civic body’s headquarters in Mumbai.
The protest, led by MNS leader Sandeep Deshpande on Monday, was aimed at ridiculing the BMC’s proposal to upgrade official vehicles after some elected representatives reportedly complained that the Scorpio-N SUVs were “too jerky” and caused back pain during travel. However, the toy cars never made it inside the civic headquarters, as security personnel stopped them at the entrance and returned them to the MNS workers.
Why is the BMC facing criticism?
The controversy stems from the BMC’s proposal to procure six Toyota Innova Crysta vehicles for key political office bearers, including the Leader of the House, the Leader of the Opposition and chairpersons of statutory committees. The proposed purchase is estimated to cost around rs 1.5 crore.
The move has drawn criticism because the existing Mahindra Scorpio-N SUVs were introduced only a few months ago at an estimated cost of around rs 20 lakh per vehicle. According to officials, several representatives complained that the SUVs ride quality was uncomfortable and resulted in back pain, prompting the administration to consider switching to the more comfort oriented Innova Crysta MPVs.
Political sparring intensifies
The proposal has quickly become a political flashpoint in Mumbai.
MNS used the toy cars to accuse the civic body of wasting public money on luxury upgrades while the city continues to grapple with infrastructure challenges.
The issue has also triggered criticism from opposition leaders. Former Mumbai mayor Kishori Pednekar questioned the need for spending public funds on new vehicles, calling the proposal unnecessary. On the other hand, Mumbai Mayor Ritu Tawde defended the plan, stating that the vehicle contract permits such changes and that concerns regarding back pain were genuine.
A debate beyond vehicles
While the proposal involves only a handful of official vehicles, it has sparked a larger debate about government spending and priorities.
Critics argue that replacing relatively new SUVs with more expensive MPVs sends the wrong message at a time when civic funds should be focused on improving roads, drainage and public services. Supporters, however, contend that elected representatives spend long hours travelling across Mumbai and should be provided with vehicles that ensure greater comfort and reduce physical strain.
What happens next?
As of now, the proposed vehicle upgrade remains under political scrutiny, with the issue dominating discussions inside and outside the BMC. Monday’s symbolic protest by the MNS has further amplified public attention, ensuring that what began as a routine procurement proposal has evolved into one of Mumbai’s most talked about civic controversies.
Whether the BMC proceeds with the Innova Crysta purchase or reconsiders the proposal is expected to depend on the outcome of the ongoing political and public debate.
ALSO READ: ‘If India Is So Great, Why Live In Dubai?’ Raj Thackeray’s Dig At Vivek Oberoi And R. Madhavan